Should You Go to College or Go Pro in MLB The Show 25 Road to the Show?

MLB The Show 25 has arrived, bringing with it a revamped Road to the Show experience. This mode lets you live the dream of becoming a major league star, but the journey begins with a crucial decision: college or the pros? This guide breaks down the pros and cons of each path.

Unlike previous iterations, MLB The Show 25 starts you as a high schooler facing this pivotal choice. Major colleges and MLB teams are vying for your signature. The decision comes after your high school season and the MLB Combine, where your performance significantly impacts your draft stock and recruitment offers.

After the Combine, you'll choose your path. Even if you opt for college, you'll still be drafted. Here's a breakdown of the options presented (based on one example):

Going Pro:

• Receive a signing bonus of 5 Tokens.
• Reduced chance of fast-tracking to the Major Leagues.
• Begin your pro career as an 18-year-old.

Going to College:

• Receive all benefits of the college's official offer (e.g., LSU).
• Increased chance of becoming the #1 overall draft pick in a future MLB Draft.
• Begin your pro career as a 21-year-old after completing your college career.

Ultimately, the choice boils down to personal preference. If you’ve toiled in the minor leagues in past games, college might be a refreshing change. Becoming the #1 overall pick is a significant achievement, offering a different, more developed entry into professional baseball. However, the grind of starting at the bottom and working your way up might be equally appealing.

In one playthrough, choosing college proved beneficial. The chance to become the #1 overall pick was too tempting to resist. The game cleverly fast-forwards to your third year, minimizing the time spent in college while still providing a rewarding experience. It's a way to get the best of both worlds.

So, there you have it—a guide to navigating the college versus pro decision in MLB The Show 25's Road to the Show. For more tips and tricks, check out our guide on the best pitching settings.

MLB The Show 25 is available now in Early Access on PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X|S.